Three Truths and a Leap of Faith
TRUTH: I get a lot of flack from friends and colleagues about the time I spend designing, arranging, decorating, and rearranging my classroom.
TRUTH: The flack is well deserved. I should be more efficient; but efficiency is not one of my strengths, and I have far too many other inadequacies that I should improve first!
TRUTH: The time I spend figuring out what types of spaces will best promote reading, writing, and thinking for my students really pays off.
The Leap: We need to give our kids a glimpse of these professional lives by letting them see, act, and feel these lives for part of their school days.
- If we want kids to be writers, we must create authentic writing spaces.
- If we want kids to be scientists, let’s create authentic science labs.
- Mathematicians? Let’s consider mathematical sciences careers, and redesign our classrooms.
After all, don’t our kids get that authenticity when visiting the art room, band room, gymnasium, and STEM room each day?
Planning Classroom Design
As I began planning my classroom design this school year, I thought about the types of places and spaces that contribute to my creativity:
Which places in my home foster deep discussion? I pictured growing up around our kitchen table, and then my mind flashed to my own family around our kitchen island, with my kiddos in their spots and my husband and I leaning in and chatting.
Where do I go to write? I’m usually at our kitchen island with my laptop- my feet elevated on another chair or sitting “crisscross-applesauce” in my chair.
Which place is my favorite reading spot? I get comfy in my reclining chair that sits next to my grandmother’s end table. There is sure to be no overhead light; just the soft light from the table lamp.
I began to look at my classroom with the same lens. I began to design spaces that authentically fostered thinking, creativity, reading, writing, and discussion.
And I did a lot of Googling. I searched “alternative classroom seating” and found Setting Up for Second which reminded me of how we all love to gather around a good, old coffee table to chat, so I decided to lower two of the trapezoid tables I already had. I also researched types of seating for students who need movement for focus and found Stabili-T-Stools. I combined these ideas with my experiences about spaces that work for me as a thinker, and this is the plan I designed:
- Students would work in groups of 3. These would be learning groups that could potentially last for 8-9 weeks or longer (If the group and I felt that they worked well together, then they could last as long as the relationship was productive. If it was not a good working relationship, we would try new strategies and readjust if needed.) This would allow students to form working relationships with each other. Productive relationships (both personal and work-related) are founded on experience and time with each other, mutual dependence, and successes earned together. I wanted to give students time to earn that, even if the relationships were rocky or uncomfortable in the beginning.
- We would have a mix of seating options with the goal of students trying different options and reflecting on what might work best for their personal learning styles and the type of work being done (independent reading, group discussion, and etc).
- We would group kids based on reading level with the intention of placing readers with others who can discuss the same book choices they make and various texts from class (Reading is the crux of the language arts curriculum in my classroom, and it is crucial for students to be able to have the time to think and to create understanding with peers at like reading levels.)
I scrounged for, gathered, begged for (Seriously, I posted on my neighborhood FB page, to which I had ZERO replies!) and bought the following items: traditional classroom desks and tables, short tables with beans bags, camp chairs with lap desks, cubes, Stabili-T-Stools, and mats.
Take a look:
Upon Reflection: Three Truths and a Leap
Different, isn’t it? A colleague who taught for me one day, when my own children were sick, teased, “She has NO desks!”
TRUTH: I’m not encouraging teachers to throw out the furniture and follow this lead.
TRUTH: I do want us to think about our classroom designs.
TRUTH: I asked myself what I wanted my students to feel when they were in my classroom. I asked myself what settings promoted reading, writing, thinking, and discussion. I wondered what students needed. I examined my personal comfort levels.
THE LEAP: About halfway through the school year, I asked students to complete a brief survey about the alternative seating in our room. One-hundred percent of students liked having alternative seating options and believed that it helped them focus on reading and writing and contributed to discussions. Ninety-five percent of students liked their current seats. Here are some student comments from the survey:
I like these types of seating because it kind of makes you feel a bit more independent. Sometimes the lack of space is too little if kids are at traditional student desks. I think kids should have a bit more space.
I like this seating because there are various ways you can arrange. It helps me learn because when I can get comfortable in different positions, then I can focus better.
This seating is very comfortable. I think the more comfortable I am, the better I can learn and pay attention because I will not be fidgeting and trying to get more comfortable
This seating style has helped me learn because I like to move around more than just sitting, so the stability stools allow me to do that.
The comments and reflections from students on this survey, and from my observations and conferences in class, will keep me on this alternative seating path. Finally, another truth? At the end of the survey, I’d asked students if there was anything else they’d like to let me know about our classroom seating. A few students suggested bicycle chairs, ball chairs, and bungee cord chairs (I’ll propose those ideas to my administrator.) A couple of other students suggested we switch partners more often (I’ll figure out what’s not working on Monday.) And one student suggested we add more windows to our classroom (I’ll let the student figure out the fundraising needed for that endeavor.)
What classroom designs work for you? What spaces and places increase student thinking? I’d love to get this conversation going.